What Did Einstein Mean By Time is an Illusion?

When you think about it, time is an arbitrary construct — it's our way of making sense of growing up and growing old. It's only a stubborn illusion that helps make sense of the world.
Jaime Trosper
A clock's particles disintegrating out of time and into space
A clock's particles disintegrating out of time and into spaceGilnature/iStock

There are all sorts of quotes about time. One of my favorite quotes is by Abhijit Naskar, the author of "Love, God & Neurons: Memoir of a scientist who found himself by getting lost." He said, “Time is basically an illusion created by the mind to aid in our sense of temporal presence in the vast ocean of space. Without the neurons to create a virtual perception of the past and the future based on all our experiences, there is no actual existence of the past and the future. All that there is, is the present.”

One of the most influential physicists to have ever lived, Albert Einstein, shared this view, writing, "People like us who believe in physics know that the distinction between past, present, and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion." In other words, time is an illusion.

When you think about it, it makes sense that time is an arbitrary construct — it's our way of making sense of growing up and growing old while the world changes around us. It's not all that hokey. So let's look at how our perception of time changes in different locations. 

It's All Relative: 

According to Einstein's own theories, time moves differently for someone below sea level than for someone situated on the highest peaks on the planet (according to some studies, "at sea level you age one-billionth of a second less every year than you would if you lived on top of Mt. Everest."). This is due to a phenomenon posited by general relativity called gravitational time dilation.

The logic behind gravitational time dilation is fairly simple: Objects with a lot of mass create a strong gravitational field. This gravitational field noticeably warps the fabric of spacetime around these objects, producing what we know as gravity. When a stream of light particles passes by an object with sufficient gravity, the stream of photons traveling at the speed of light appears to bend. 

What's even more interesting is that mass can warp the fabric of time itself, causing it to move slower or faster depending on how massive the object is and how strong the object's gravitational pull is, which is where time dilation becomes wonky to us.

What Did Einstein Mean By Time is an Illusion?
An astronaut venturing into a black hole.Source: NASA [astronaut]; NASA/ESA and G. Bacon, STScI [black hole illustration]

It should be noted, however, that an observer in the strong gravity experiences time as running normally. It is only in relation to a reference frame with weaker gravity that time runs slowly. 

Time appears to pass normally to a person in strong gravity, while a clock in weak gravity runs fast. While to the person in weak gravity, the clock appears to run normally, and the clock in strong gravity runs slowly. Of course, there is nothing wrong with the clocks. Time is slowing down and speeding up because of the relativistic way mass warps space and time.

The faster one moves, the slower time passes in relation to a static observer's perception. Matter traveling at the speed of light does not really experience time or distance, at least relative to a static point. Just watching a spaceship drift off into deep space, the people on Earth view the ship as moving much more slowly through space and time than the people on the ship perceive it to be moving. Crew members would also age slower the faster they move.

Making Time Dilation Easy:

Take another cool example: The movie "Interstellar" in which time dilation is demonstrated (spoilers beyond, obviously). In the movie, a crew leaves Earth searching for a habitable planet to which we could flee a dying Earth. At one point in the film, a few crew members land on a water world near a gargantuan black hole/wormhole. Given the proximity to the super-dense stellar object, the planet experiences unimaginably volatile waves, and the time dilation becomes extreme. One hour on the surface was equal to 7 years for someone beyond the black hole's orbit. 

Astronauts on the ISS experience a much less dramatic form of time dilation, given that the International Space Station is not traveling near relativistic speeds. Two twin astronauts were part of an experiment conducted by NASA; they calculated that the twin who spent the most time in space, aged 5 milliseconds more than his Earth-bound twin.

It Gets Even Weirder:

Perhaps the strangest example of time dilation can be seen in and around black holes. Time ticks much differently the closer you get to the event horizon of a black hole. Imagine that you had two clocks — one held by an observer beyond the immensely strong gravity of the object and another held by an observer passing near the event horizon — the clock farther away would tick faster than the one close to the event horizon. 

From the point of view of the observer near the event horizon, one day may have passed, while the person observing from the outside may have experienced a decade. Eventually, time may appear to stop altogether for the observer near the event horizon.

From the outside, the observer at the event horizon would begin to redshift, which means the wavelength of light they emit would move toward the red portion of the electromagnetic spectrum until the light becomes dimmer and dimmer. Inevitably, time would appear to stop altogether before the observer plunges into the event horizon. In theory, we would never actually see this occur, as the object would appear to freeze and never actually disappear into the black hole.  

Black holes can be formed when a massive star reaches the end of its life; its core begins to collapse in on itself, spitting out large quantities of gas and dust in a supernova event. The star must be at least three times as massive as our Sun for this process to occur. It is thought that supermassive black holes, which range from 100,000 to tens of billions of times the mass of the Sun, may be formed by a sort of chain reaction, and this is where extreme time dilation comes in. 

Devoured By a Big Ole Black Hole:

If you're wondering what actually happens when something finally gets sucked into the event horizon — the point at which nothing, not even photons (or light itself) can travel faster than the object's escape velocity, thus there's no chance of escaping its grasp — the physics gets rather convoluted and our understanding of how things work begins to fall apart. 

It's believed that an observer inside a black hole would eventually stop experiencing time altogether. Still, they would become stretched out as the black hole slowly ripped them apart — atom by atom. This is called spaghettification, The forces of gravity during a so-called "tidal disruption event" would pull harder on your head vs. your feet, and you'd be shredded. 

What Did Einstein Mean By Time is an Illusion?
Artist rendering of a star undergoing spaghettification as it’s devoured by a supermassive black hole during a so-called ‘tidal disruption event.' Source:ESO/M. Kornmesser

Thankfully, we can sometimes measure these events, at least when they happen to other stellar objects. This is because they produce a lot of energy we can detect using specialized telescopes, like the ESO. Often gas and dust obscure our view, but if we catch an event at the right time, we can study just what happens when a supermassive black hole devours matter. 

As For Einstein...

As we saw from Einstein's quote, he believed that time is an illusion, that both the future and the past are unchangeable, and will play out exactly the way they were meant to.

Many physicists share this view, but some have alternate explanations for how things will play out in the long run. One suggests that the present, future, and past are mostly unwritten. Or, they are all playing out at the same time. The Block Universe Theory contributes a lot to these ideals.

Overall, do you think Einstein was right or wrong?

Add Interesting Engineering to your Google News feed.
Add Interesting Engineering to your Google News feed.
message circleSHOW COMMENT (1)chevron
Job Board